Good preparation is timeless,” she says. “It matters in every market and at every price point. It gives you more options, allows you to be more strategic and puts you in a stronger position when it is time to sell. And that preparation can become your competitive advantage.
Here is the exact checklist she would follow.
1. Capture the Property at Its Best
“If selling in the winter or the spring were even a possibility, I would arrange professional photography and video in the summer—or in the fall, if the decision came later.”
In Muskoka, the landscape changes quickly. Once the dock is out, the leaves are down and the gardens have disappeared, buyers lose part of the picture.
“They want to see the shoreline, water entry, outdoor spaces and how the property feels during the season they imagine enjoying it most,” Melissa says.
Additional photographs can always be taken closer to the listing date. Summer cannot be recreated in March.
Strong seasonal imagery also gives buyers greater confidence when viewing a property during the shoulder season. It helps them understand what they are buying—and what they have to look forward to.
As an added bonus, your property also stands out online, where most buyers will discover it first.
2. Complete a Pre-Listing Inspection
“Unpopular opinion: I would complete a pre-listing inspection before going to market. I believe in being proactive, and this shows buyers you are willing to be an open book. It reflects pride of ownership and begins building trust before negotiations. Let me explain.”
A pre-listing inspection creates an opportunity to uncover surprises, address maintenance items and small repairs, and obtain professional advice where needed.
“Once you are negotiating an offer, time is limited and emotions can be unpredictable,” Melissa says. “Knowing the condition of the property allows you to enter negotiations informed, prepared and confident in your position.”
A buyer may still choose to complete their own inspection. The pre-listing inspection establishes transparency from the beginning, gives both sides greater confidence and creates a stronger foundation of trust throughout negotiations.
3. Service the Mechanicals and Address Small Maintenance Items
“I would service the major mechanical systems before going to market and keep every receipt,” Melissa says. “That may include the furnace, air conditioning or heat pumps, generator, water system, fireplace and chimney. If appropriate, I would also have the septic tank pumped.”
Buyers notice this level of detail. It signals pride of ownership and gives them confidence in how the property has been cared for. That confidence can influence how they view the property and how they enter negotiations.
In some cases, thorough service records and supporting documentation may even influence whether a buyer includes a home inspection condition in their offer.
“I would also address the smaller maintenance items—loose handles, dripping taps, damaged screens—and never underestimate a fresh coat of paint,” Melissa says. “It can soften signs of everyday wear, brighten a room, improve the photographs and make the entire property feel better cared for.”
4. Start Packing Before You List
“I would start downsizing and packing long before the listing photographs were scheduled,” Melissa says.
Buyers often read crowded rooms, cupboards and closets as a lack of space. Removing the excess makes rooms feel larger, storage more generous and the property easier to appreciate.
- Pack anything you will not need for the next several months.
- Donate or sell what will not be moving with you.
- Remove extra furniture that makes a room feel crowded.
- Edit the cupboards, closets and storage areas buyers will open.
This also sets the stage for staging, allowing each room to have a clear purpose and its best features to stand out.
And if the right offer comes with a quick closing, you’ll be glad much of the packing is already done.
5. Gather the Information Buyers Will Ask For
Collect all the important property documents and have them available to the buyer.
Depending on the property, that may include:
- Septic permits and service/pump out receipts
- Well or water-system information and a recent water test
- Survey(s)
- Private road or maintenance agreements, if applicable
- Utility and operating costs
- Rental history, if applicable
- Receipts and warranties for major improvements
- Shore road allowance ownership, etc.
Complete documentation allows buyers to understand the property and make informed decisions with greater confidence.
Missing information creates questions. Unanswered questions create hesitation.
As a bonus, if the property had development or severance potential, I would ask an independent planner to provide preliminary comments in writing. It offers no guarantees, but it can save buyers time and give them another helpful layer of information.
6. Understand the Market You Are Preparing For
“The market you prepare in may not be the market you eventually list in,” Melissa says. “I would speak with a local broker early and build the plan around what buyers are doing now—and where the market appears to be heading.”
Ask:
- What is selling, and what is sitting?
- What are buyers becoming more selective about?
- What is the absorption rate—what percentage of listed properties are actually selling?
- What preparation matters most at my price point?
- When is the best time to list my type of product?
- When is the best time to list a property like mine?
No one can predict the market with certainty. However, current sales, inventory and buyer behaviour provide valuable direction.
Timing should influence the preparation, pricing and launch strategy.
Early advice gives you time to make informed decisions—and the flexibility to adjust before you are under pressure to sell.
7. Make Improvements That Earn Their Place
“I would be very careful about completing major improvements solely for resale,” Melissa says. “Before spending the money, I would ask whether the work will improve value, build buyer confidence or remove a meaningful objection.”
Fresh paint, completed maintenance, updated lighting and stronger presentation can offer a clear return. A costly renovation based on personal taste may not.
The right improvements will also vary by property, price point and buyer expectations. Speak with a local broker before committing to the work.
“Every dollar should have a purpose.”
Good preparation means knowing what will matter to the next buyer—and investing accordingly.
Put Time on Your Side
“If I were selling my own property, I would want time on my side—to be proactive, gather the right information, create the best first impression and build a strong strategy.”
A successful sale begins well before the price is chosen and the sign goes up.
Who in your circle needs to read this?
Share it with a friend or family member considering a sale in the year ahead.
If you’re considering a move in Muskoka, having a trusted local expert in your corner matters more than ever.
Melissa Bradbury and her team, trusted by HGTV’s Scott McGillivray, bring over a decade of experience helping buyers make confident, well-informed decisions in Muskoka.
Early conversations lead to better decisions.
And now is the right time to start one.
Call 705-646-5300 or visit perylekeye.ca for personalized guidance.
Follow @perylekeye on on Instagram, Facebook, and YouTube for insider tips, market updates, and a closer look at Muskoka’s most remarkable properties.
Back to Media